Best Pizza in Town

Wesley Chapel's neighborhood pizzeria

NY-style pizza, made the right way

Plain cheese, gourmet, or build your own — every pie starts with the crust and the sauce, and we don't rush either one.

The Cheese Calzone

Our Cheese Calzone is a house favorite — regulars order it every visit. The Tiramisu and BBQ Chicken Pizza have their own followings too.

From the kitchen

Independent. No shortcuts.

We're not a chain, and we never will be. Every choice we make — from the crust to the sauce — is ours alone.

Our story

I was happy to discover Caprese Pizza House because it's walking distance from my new home, but I was blown away when I tried the actual pizza! I ordered a Original White, add pepperoni, spinach, and mushrooms. The toppings are nicely balanced to cover all slices. The seasoning is the star of the show though!! I feel like most chain places don't use seasoning anymore except for what's in the sauce. This is so bursting with flavor though! You can taste and see the herbs! Job well done…

Marcus S.

I consider myself a pizza connoisseur. We started with the garlic knots and they we AWESOME! Light and very tasteful. Then an X-Large pizza. Their pizza will be hard to beat. Was extremely pleased. Will be back again for either dining in or carry out. One of the best pizzas in the Wesley Chapel area.

David L.

I'm 70 and have eaten Philly steak sandwiches all my life and all over this world, this was hands down the best steak sandwich I have ever had, It might be the best sandwich I have ever had.

Scott B.

One of the best pizzas in Wesley Chapel. Been here twice. Very thin crust and plenty of yum toppings, and very affordable, will come back! ~ Was a 25 min then 5 min wait on a weekday around lunch time. We got a large mixed with 2 halves of: ++ chicken parmigiana with ricotta tomato + eggplant parmigiana with ricotta tomato + Philly cheese steak with green bell peppers ++ tiramisu was amazing

Ana S.

Love that this place is so close to our neighborhood (Kbar Ranch). Probably some of the best and most consistent pizza we have had since living here in Tampa. We get the caprese special calzone and half cheese/pepperoni pizza, it’s amazing quality! . They have been on time with the time quoted with pickup, never have messed our order up! . Amazing place for your New York style pizza!!

Blair L.